Skip to content

Out and About: Castro

The first half of 2025 hasn’t been kind to preservation in San Francisco: delayed hearings of the North Beach National Register historic district, the mayor’s proposed elimination of the Legacy Business Registry program manager position (restored in the budget by the Board of Supervisors), and now a plan to demolish a city landmark—help us with the last by writing to you supervisor.  

But some hopeful news is Supervisor Chan’s support for extending legacy business anti-displacement measures, something that may provide assistance to a Castro business that we’re spotlighting today. 

The part of Eureka Valley which became known as the Castro in the 1960s and ‘70s is today one of the most well-known LGBTQ+ enclaves in the world. Now, it has been chosen as the first district to kick-off a Planning-led and SF Heritage-supported landmarking initiative. So grab a Hot Cookie and follow us on our Out and About August spotlight!  

collage featuring white SF Heritage logo, and cutouts of Central Drug Store, Haas-Lilienthal House, Doolan-Larson Building, and neon legacy business signs
Trivia Question

Q: What and where is “Nobby Clarke’s Folly?”

Answer at the bottom. **This week, one lucky reader will receive two free passes to the GLBT Historical Society Museum! Reply to this email and tell us one of your favorite places in the Castro for a chance to win. If you don’t want to try your luck, reserve tickets for a future visit to this legacy business here. 

GLBT Historical Society passes for free admission on a white table
Cultural District Spotlight

The Castro LGBTQ Cultural District was formed in 2019 to preserve, sustain, and promote the rich cultural legacy of the Castro and its significance to the LGBTQ+ community in San Francisco and beyond. 

One of the cultural district’s recent arts accomplishments was the completion of Serge Gay Jr.’s Circle of Change, a mural of four Black lesbians and transgender women located on a building at 4122 18th St. in the Castro.

Your friends from out-of-town might still have heard of the Castro, one of the most well-known LGBTQ+ neighborhoods in the United States for over fifty years and a space the cultural district champions for its “unparalleled history of queer placemaking, political organizing, cultural development, and visibility.” 

The cultural district helped lead the Friends of Castro Theatre Coalition (SF Heritage was a member) and its advocacy for the preservation of the theatre’s historic interior and its continuance as a space of LGBTQ+ cultural production. As a result of this work, the Historic Preservation Commission and Planning Department voted to approve conditions for the future operation of the theatre, including a percentage of LGBTQ+ programming and a community engagement and oversight process. Photo by Daniel Cunningham. 

Neighborhood institutions like the Castro Country Club, Twin Peaks Tavern, the SF LGBT Center (fiscal sponsor of the cultural district), GLBT Historical Society, and Fabulosa Books make the district a rare place created by and for LGBTQ+ people—a population that continues to face state-sponsored repression, invisibility, social stigma, and violence around the world. Part of the cultural district’s work is acknowledging and supporting these important and historic neighborhood spaces.  

The adoption in 2024 of the cultural district’s Cultural History, Housing, and Economic Sustainability Strategy (CHHESS) report—a strategic plan required of each city cultural district—was a major step forward in this work.

Castro LGBTQ CHHESS report cover
Cover of the district’s CHHESS Report. *Click to read the full report*

The 111-page report created over three years details strategies for historic preservation, housing, economic development, arts, and culture: 

  • Ensuring the city prioritizes further local, state, and national landmark nominations of Castro LGBTQ+ historical sites, notably those representing the experiences of women, BIPOC individuals, bisexuals, and transgender and gender-nonconforming people. 
  • Collaborating with local housing organizations to develop affordable housing strategies that may include land trusts and for people engaged in community organizations.
  • Recognizing historically significant businesses to support their longevity and increase commercial vitality. 

Preservation strategies like the CHHESS are importantly the foundation for ongoing support, resources, and funding from the city and beyond. 

Legacy Business Spotlight
The large selection of coffees and coffee-making equipment inside the Coffee Company.

You can’t miss the beloved Castro Theatre building when visiting the neighborhood. While the landmark’s neon blade sign and marquee dominate the streetscape, the two businesses on its ground floor are integral to the neighborhood’s cultural vitality. 

Flanking each side of the theatre’s entrance are The Castro Coffee Company (427 Castro Street) and the Castro Nail Salon (431 Castro Street), owned by brothers Ken and Riyad Khoury respectively.  

Ken, 74, has been in the coffee shop space since 1987 (originally the Castro Cheesery). For decades, the walk-in-closet-sized cafe has maintained a daily carousel of customers who choose favorites from dozens of different coffee (and tea!) blends. A familiar sight in the Castro is walking past the customers enjoying their drinks at the Coffee Company’s sidewalk tables. Ken’s brother Riyad, 78, opened the nail salon in 2004, one of the first in the district. A participant in the Department of the Environment’s Healthy Nail Salons Program, it promotes safer nail products, has better ventilation, and provides training for its employees, some of whom have worked in the salon for more than a decade. 

Now, these two businesses face eviction. Another Planet Entertainment, lease holder for the Castro Theatre currently closed for renovations, seeks to repurpose the spaces for a ticketing office. Castro Nail Salon’s inclusion on the Legacy Business Registry may provide some needed assistance. In 2024, former District 3 supervisor Aaron Peskin, with support from SF Heritage, introduced and passed an 18-month zoning control measure requiring conditional use permits for demolishing or displacing a legacy business. Just a few weeks ago, supervisor Connie Chan proposed making this measure permanent.  

The Castro LGBTQ Cultural District and several community members have led advocacy to retain the Khourys’s long-standing businesses in the theatre building. SF Heritage supports the effort and encourages Another Planet to find a solution to keep both in the Castro. Stop by each business to show your support, and see Woody’s note below.

Landmark Spotlight
SF AIDS Foundation building at 514-520 Castro Street. SF Heritage photo.

Historic preservation documentation like the cultural district’s CHHESS report provides the foundation for a myriad of preservation actions, including the protection, identification, interpretation, and designation of significant sites and places.  

Earlier this year, the Planning Department selected District 8, which includes the Castro, as the first district in a new Expanding Choice Landmark Program. Many of the proposed landmarks were chosen directly from a list of historic resources documented by the San Francisco LGBTQ Historic Context Statement (2015) by Donna Graves and Shayne Watson.

Proposed landmarks in District 8, displayed by the Planning Department at a community meeting in April 2025.

Some of the proposed new landmarks are the two-story San Francisco AIDS Foundation building (514-520 Castro Street), which housed one of the first agencies in the United States specifically addressing AIDS (founded in 1982); the distinctive Bank of Italy Branch Building (400-410 Castro Street), which today has transformed into a destination for spin classes (SoulCycle); and the former site of the Missouri Mule (2348 Market Street). Now home to the club Beau, the one-story building was the site of the Castro’s very first documented gay bar.       

Bank of Italy Branch Building

400-410 Castro Street

Former site of the Missouri Mule

2348 Market Street

We encourage Planning to continue these district-by-district landmarking efforts to ensure that our historic resources are preserved for future generations.  

Woody LaBounty President and CEO

San Francisco has big plans to rezone a majority of the city in coming months. Greater height allowance around transit-rich intersections and corridors like Castro and Market streets are intended to incentivize new housing construction. Recent state laws are also meant to attract and streamline big developments. 

Historic designation, which includes city landmark status, is one of the few tools available to ensure adequate local review and oversight is conducted when a historic site is proposed for new development. As we streamline housing production and density, we need to at the same time streamline historic designation and ensure that our legacy businesses are not displaced. 

Let District 8 supervisor Raphael Mandelman know how much San Francisco special places mean to you and that you support increased protections for historic resources. 

Trivia Answer
The Alfred E Clarke mansion under construction at 250 Douglass Street, circa 1891. San Francisco Call Bulletin photo, San Francisco History Center, SF Public Library.

Q:  What and where is “Nobby Clarke’s Folly?”

A: Nobby Clarke’s Folly was the nickname given to the house built by Alfred E Clarke at 250 Douglass Street (at Caselli) in the Castro. The grand home was constructed in 1891-92 when the still-growing suburban village had little more than one and two-story cottages. 

Clarke was a former police officer and clerk who reportedly made his fortune by lending money to patrolmen, which eventually got him fired from his position. After leaving the police force, Clarke spent years as an attorney filing lawsuits against the Police Commissioner and Police Department on behalf of rank-and-file members.  

Clarke had ongoing feuds over water and property issues with Behrend Joost, his neighbor further up the slope. The two had competing water companies, but the poor quality from Clarke’s wells led the San Francisco Board of Health to condemn them for domestic use in 1891. 

Investment failures forced Clarke into bankruptcy and he lost his home in 1896. the building was converted into its present use as apartments in 1909. It was designated as SF Landmark no. 80. in November 1975. 

The mansion today (sans chimney), now apartments. SF Heritage photo.
Take a guided tour of the Historic Haas-Lilienthal House before the end of the summer tour season

Visit the historic Haas-Lilienthal House before we pause tours to make way for our annual haunted house transformation for Halloween. SF Heritage is pleased to offer Wednesday and Saturday afternoon tours each week. Each are led by one of SF Heritage’s amazing docents. Book your spot here through August 2025.

Join the next Heritage Happy Hour/Annual Legacy Business Mixer (August 14)

Register for our next Heritage Happy Hour at the EndUp on Thursday, August 14, 5-7 pm!

Heritage Happy Hours are convivial no-host celebrations of San Francisco legacy businesses, hosted every second Thursday of the month by SF Heritage and the Legacy Business Program of San Francisco’s Office of Small Business. RSVP for free here

Help us revitalize the corner of Haight and Ashbury

Starting August 1, San Francisco Heritage is now accepting proposals to reimagine the landmark Doolan-Larson House and Storefronts on the corner of Haight and Ashbury streets.

We envision this project as a national model for adaptive reuse—demonstrating how historic preservation has an essential place in contemporary culture and civic life. Help share our announcement with those who might be interested!

Tags
Legacy BusinessesLandmarkCastrolandmark-worthycultural districtsout and aboutCastro LGBTQ Cultural District

Related posts

Previous post
Next post

Sign up for our newsletter

Get SF Heritage e-news directly to your inbox by signing up for Special City!

Back To Top
Search